What Does “Burned” Mean?
A domain or inbox is considered burned when its performance drops significantly compared to its own historical baseline, indicating deliverability degradation or spam placement.
Burn status is contextual, not absolute.
Signals Used to Determine Burn Status
Peeker evaluates multiple performance signals together, including:
Reply rates
Bounce rates
Daily performance trends
Historical averages over time
Warm-up status and duration
Sending volume relative to prior behavior
These signals are evaluated on a per domain and per campaign basis.
Contextual Performance Analysis
Peeker does not rely on static rules or simple if then logic.
Instead, the system compares:
Current performance
Against the same domain’s historical averages
Against recent performance within the same workspace
Example:
If a domain consistently produces a 3 percent reply rate month over month, and suddenly drops to 0.5 percent without any changes to copy, offer, or lead list, this is treated as a strong indicator of a burned state.
The system then applies a rule set relative to that domain and campaign to determine burn status.
What Peeker Does Not Use
Peeker does not rely on inbox placement tests to determine burn status.
Inbox placement testing:
Is often unreliable
Is especially inaccurate for Microsoft Azure infrastructure
Can be misleading even for Google infrastructure
For Google inboxes, placement tests may be semi accurate, but results from third party vendors should always be interpreted cautiously.
Why Reply Rate Drops Matter Most
The most reliable indicator of a burned domain is a sustained drop in reply rates when other variables remain unchanged.
If:
Copy is the same
Offer is the same
Lead list quality is consistent
And reply rates drop sharply, this strongly suggests deliverability issues rather than messaging problems.
Warm-Up and Volume Considerations
Peeker also factors in:
Whether warm-up was completed
The number of warm-up days
Sending volume changes
Sudden spikes or inconsistencies
Improper warm-up or aggressive volume increases can contribute to a burned status.
Accuracy and Limitations
Peeker’s burn detection algorithm is highly accurate, but it is not perfect.
Important caveats:
Cold email has many moving parts
External factors can affect performance
No detection system can be 100 percent accurate
Burn status is determined using your own data and historical averages, which provides a high degree of confidence compared to generic rules.
Summary
Burn status is determined contextually
Reply rates and historical trends are the strongest signals
Inbox placement tests are not used
Warm-up and volume behavior are factored in
Results are based on your own data, not global thresholds
Burn detection is highly accurate but not infallible
Why Burned Status Matters
When an inbox is burned, its ability to reach the inbox (not spam) for recipients is severely reduced. Early detection and replacement protect your campaigns from being marked as spam and maintain your domain's reputation.

